Carlos Gu has come under fire online after becoming visibly emotional during last night’s episode of Strictly Come Dancing, where he broke down in tears while speaking to co-host Claudia Winkleman. The moment, which followed an emotional American Smooth routine, drew both praise and criticism from viewers.

Former Lioness and football pundit Karen Carney performed with her professional partner Carlos to You Don’t Own Me by Saygrace featuring G-Eazy. Despite the technical challenges presented by her long-standing spinal condition, the judges noted significant improvements in her posture, flow and upper-body movement.

Carney has been open about suffering from Scheuermann’s disease, a condition that causes abnormal curvature of the spine and can make ballroom dancing “really hard,” especially when the choreography demands wide, elegant lines and an open frame (source: BBC Sport).

Judges praise Karen’s progression

After their performance, Craig Revel Horwood complimented Karen’s stage presence and development, telling her: “You are absolutely gorgeous. I love watching you dance… I just adore this partnership.” Motsi Mabuse echoed this, calling the number “beautiful,” while head judge Shirley Ballas delivered the feedback that left Carlos in tears.

Ballas highlighted Karen’s clear progression since week one, adding: “Your posture has come along so beautifully. I see your hard work… there were so many improvements, so well done.” Her words appeared to overwhelm Carlos, who had to be comforted by presenter Tess Daly as he struggled to contain his emotions.

Carlos breaks down in the Claudiatorium

When the pair reached Claudia Winkleman upstairs, the pro dancer continued to weep as he reflected on Karen’s journey.
“She worked so hard this week,” he told Claudia. “Ballroom is not her strength, but she came in and said: ‘Carlos, I really want to try. I know my back has problems, but I want to push myself.’ Hearing the judges acknowledge that… you have no idea how hard she’s been working.”

Karen, who had earned her first 10 of the series the week prior, was also moved to tears as she watched Carlos break down beside her. The moment quickly spread on social media, with many praising Carlos for his sincerity and support for his partner.

Viewers divided over emotional moment

Dozens of viewers shared their emotional reactions online. “Carlos, I’m crying as well — please stop, it’s breaking my heart,” one wrote. Another added: “I’m in tears after Kaz and Carlos’ dance… it must be lovely for the pro when the judges acknowledge that improvement.”

Several others noted Carlos’s openness, writing: “Blimey! He’s wearing his heart on his sleeve tonight,” and “I wasn’t expecting to cry over this of all things, but Carlos has me weeping. He is the sweetest.”

However, not everyone appreciated the display. Some viewers felt the reaction was excessive, with criticisms spreading on X (formerly Twitter). One user wrote: “Carlos and Karen need to get a grip – it’s not the end of the world.” Another complained: “All this crying on #Strictly is doing my head in. It’s just way too over the top this year.” Others even accused him of “fake crying,” claiming the emotional response felt forced.

Similar debates have occurred in previous Strictly seasons, particularly when contestants or pros become visibly emotional after intense rehearsal periods — something several performers have said is inevitable given the pressure, injuries and gruelling schedule (source: Radio Times; The Guardian).

A routine that meant more than scores

Despite the divided public reaction, Karen and Carlos ended their segment united in their pride for the performance. For Karen, whose spinal condition continues to influence her approach to the competition, the judges’ recognition marked a milestone. For Carlos, it was a moment that reflected both his coaching dedication and his bond with his partner — a dynamic many fans have praised since the start of the series.