Its public database allows people to view information about missing children, including photographs, identifying details, and other information that may help generate leads.
For someone with no clear account of his first years of life, the website offered a possible starting point.
Steve searched for children reported missing in Hawaii.
He did not necessarily expect to find anything connected to himself. He was simply looking through cases in the state where he had been born and where he had spent his earliest years.
But one result immediately changed the atmosphere of the search.
A photograph appeared.
It showed a baby boy.
Alongside the original photograph was an age-progressed image representing what the child might look like as an adult.
The missing child's name was Marx Panama Moriarty Barnes.
Steve stared at the image.
The more he looked at it, the more uncomfortable the resemblance became. It was not merely that the child had a vaguely familiar appearance. The adult composite seemed to share distinctive facial characteristics with him.
He later recalled the shock of seeing an image that looked so much like himself.
His first reaction was essentially disbelief.
Could this really be connected to him?
The case information offered several additional details that made the resemblance even more difficult to dismiss.
The missing child had disappeared in Hawaii in 1977. He had been only a few months old. His birth date was close to Steve's own, although the dates recorded in the different documents were not perfectly identical.
The location was the same.
The approximate age at which the child had entered the missing-person system was consistent with the period before Steve's placement in institutional care.
And the photograph looked remarkably familiar.
Suddenly, the late-issued birth certificate and the unexplained years in the orphanage seemed more significant than they had ever appeared before.
Steve had entered the website hoping to learn something about his past.
Instead, he had found a missing-child case that might explain nearly everything.
The Photograph That Changed His Understanding of Himself
There are moments when a person encounters information that cannot immediately be absorbed.
For Steve, seeing the photograph of Marx Barnes was one of those moments.
He was looking at a picture of a baby he had never met, yet something about the image seemed deeply personal.
He did not have a collection of baby photographs from his own first months to compare against it. In fact, the photograph on the missing-child website was reportedly the first picture of himself as an infant that he had ever seen.
That made the discovery even more powerful.
Until then, his earliest life had largely existed as a series of incomplete records and secondhand explanations.
Now, for the first time, he was looking at an image that might represent his actual beginnings.
The age-progression image created an additional emotional shock.
Age-progression illustrations are designed to estimate how a missing child might appear as they grow older. They are not photographs of the person as an adult, nor are they guarantees of what someone will look like decades later.
They are investigative tools that can help generate recognition and possible leads.
In Steve's case, the resemblance appeared unusually compelling.
He shared the image with friends and asked them what they thought.
Their reactions encouraged him to take the possibility seriously. He also sent the image to his adoptive parents.
His adoptive mother, Pat, was reportedly struck by the resemblance as well.
There was an obvious problem, however.
The Carter family had adopted Steve when he was four years old. The missing-child case concerned a baby who had disappeared when he was approximately six months old.
How could those two histories belong to the same person?
At first glance, they seemed incompatible.
If the baby had been missing since 1977, why had he later entered an orphanage? How had he been identified? Why had the authorities not connected the child in state care with the missing-person report?
And if Steve really was that baby, why had his adoptive family never been told?
These were not questions that a visual resemblance could answer.
A computer-generated image could suggest a connection, but it could not establish identity.
Steve needed something more reliable.
He needed investigators to examine the records and determine whether the boy listed as Marx Barnes and the man known as Steve Carter were the same person.
He eventually decided to contact the Honolulu Police Department.
That decision transformed a private moment of disbelief into a formal missing-child investigation.
Contacting the Authorities
When Steve contacted law enforcement, he was not presenting an ordinary adoption inquiry.
He was asking authorities to investigate whether he might be a person who had been reported missing more than three decades earlier.
The Honolulu Police Department had the responsibility of examining the original missing-child case and determining whether the new information could lead to a credible identification.
Steve provided what he knew about his adoption, his birthplace, his birth certificate, and the unusual circumstances surrounding his early childhood.
The investigators could then compare those details with the information associated with Marx Barnes.
The similarities were significant enough to justify further examination.
There was the shared Hawaiian birthplace. There was the close relationship between the recorded birth dates. There was the missing child's photograph and the striking age-progression resemblance.
There was also Steve's unexplained placement in the Hawaiian child welfare system at approximately the same period when Marx had disappeared.
Still, investigators could not simply assume that the two identities were connected.
Missing-person cases require evidence.
Names can be changed. Birth dates can be recorded incorrectly. Families can move. Children can enter care under incomplete or misleading information.
Even a convincing visual resemblance cannot replace a formal identification process.
The next major step was DNA testing.
In February 2011, Steve provided a DNA sample as part of the investigation.
The sample would be compared with biological family reference material to establish whether he was genetically related to the people connected to the original missing-child case.
For Steve, this meant waiting.
He had already spent decades living without knowing the identity of his biological family. Now he had discovered a possible answer, but he could not yet be certain that it was true.
The waiting period must have been difficult to process.
There was the possibility of discovering that he had a biological father who had been searching for him for years.
There was the possibility of learning that he had sisters and other relatives he had never known existed.
There was also the possibility that the apparent resemblance was misleading and that he would have to return to the uncertainty that had followed him throughout his life.
The investigation continued for months.
According to contemporary reporting, the DNA testing was conducted after Steve contacted authorities, and the final confirmation arrived approximately eight months later.
The result would provide an answer that no photograph, birth certificate, or family recollection could establish on its own.
Steve Carter was Marx Panama Moriarty Barnes.
The missing-child case had finally been solved.
The Identity Behind the Name Steve Carter
The confirmation was more than a correction to a birth certificate.
It meant that Steve had been living with a different identity from the one given to him at birth for nearly his entire life.
His original name was Marx Panama Moriarty Barnes.
The name itself carried a family history that Steve had never known.
According to reporting at the time, his biological father, Mark Barnes, later explained that the name Marx had been chosen in reference to Karl Marx, while Panama was connected to the nickname of his godfather.
These were details that might seem small to someone who had always known their parents and family traditions.