That is why sudden endings are especially painful, a point the original article returns to later. A sudden ending denies a person the information they need to make sense of what happened. Was it something I did? Was it something they were going through? Did they ever care? Without answers, the mind supplies its own, and those supplied answers are often harsher than the truth. Self-blame, as Boelen and Reijntjes found, is one of the strongest correlates of emotional problems after a breakup, precisely because it offers a false sense of explanation: if it was my fault, then at least I understand why it happened, and at least I can prevent it next time by being different [16]. That logic is understandable, but it is also a trap, because it places the entire weight of another person's choices on the person who was hurt by them.
Moving on, in the research literature, is therefore less about willpower than about three things: time, new learning, and support. Time allows old associations to weaken. New learning, through new experiences, new routines, and new relationships, gives the brain new associations to strengthen. Support, from friends, family, or a therapist, provides the safe haven that the lost relationship briefly seemed to offer, and that safety makes it possible to process the loss rather than merely enduring it. A person who tries to move on by suppressing all feeling, by immediately entering a new relationship to prove they are over the old one, or by punishing themselves for still caring, is often delaying the process rather than accelerating it. The feelings do not disappear because they are ignored. They wait, and they return, often at a less convenient time.
It is also worth noting that moving on does not mean the same thing for everyone. For some people, it means no longer thinking about the other person daily. For others, it means being able to think about them without a surge of pain. For still others, it means being able to trust again, or to enjoy intimacy again without fear. All of those are legitimate definitions, and a person should be allowed to define their own. The original article's phrase, difficult to fully move on, captures that ambiguity well. Moving on is not a single event. It is a gradual shift in how much space a past experience occupies in a person's present life, and that shift happens in small, often unnoticed steps: a day without checking, a week without dreaming, a moment of laughter that is not followed by guilt.
5. Self-Doubt and the Questioning of Judgment
Another challenge is the development of self-doubt. People may begin questioning their own judgment, wondering whether they ignored warning signs or misunderstood the other person's intentions. Repeated negative experiences can gradually damage confidence and make trusting future partners more difficult.
Self-doubt after a disappointing intimate experience is rarely about a single decision. It is about the story a person tells about their own judgement. Did I miss the signs? Was I naive? Did I want to believe them so much that I ignored what was in front of me? Those questions are painful, but they are also, in moderation, useful. They are the mind's way of trying to learn, of scanning the past for information that might protect the future. The problem arises when the questions stop being a search for information and become a verdict: I am someone who cannot judge people, I am someone who always chooses badly, I am someone who cannot be trusted with my own heart.
That shift, from a question to a verdict, is where confidence is damaged. Research on self-esteem after breakups has found that negative self-esteem significantly predicts avoidance and poorer general health, and that people with lower self-esteem are more likely to experience post-traumatic stress symptoms after a relationship ends [18]. The mechanism is partly cognitive: a person with low self-esteem is more likely to interpret an ambiguous event, such as a partner's silence, as evidence of their own inadequacy, rather than as evidence of the partner's limitations, circumstances, or choices. It is partly behavioural: a person who doubts their judgement may avoid new relationships altogether, or may enter them with such vigilance that closeness becomes impossible, or may accept poor treatment because they believe they do not deserve better. Each of those behaviours, in turn, can confirm the original doubt, creating a cycle that is hard to break without help.
Warning signs are a complicated part of this story, because they are much clearer in hindsight than they were at the time. Psychologists call this hindsight bias: once an outcome is known, the events that led to it seem as if they should have been obvious. A person who has been hurt may look back and see a dozen signs they missed, a cancelled plan, a vague answer, a reluctance to introduce friends, a pattern of only contacting them late at night, and conclude that they were foolish not to have seen them. At the time, however, each of those signs was ambiguous. A cancelled plan could have been a genuine emergency. A vague answer could have been shyness. A reluctance to introduce friends could have been a slow pace rather than a secret. People in the early stages of a relationship are also motivated to interpret ambiguity generously, because hope and desire make generosity feel natural. That is not foolishness. It is how human beings form bonds: by giving the other person the benefit of the doubt, at least at first.
The more useful question, therefore, is not whether a person missed signs, but whether they had the information, the support, and the self-trust to act on the signs they did see. Many people do see signs, and still proceed, because they hope the signs are wrong, because they fear losing the connection, because they have been taught that asking for clarity is demanding, or because they have learned from past experience that their needs will be dismissed if they voice them. Those are not failures of intelligence. They are adaptations to earlier experiences, and they can be unlearned, but only with patience and support.
Repeated negative experiences compound the problem. A single disappointing encounter can be processed as an exception. A second, a third, and a fourth begin to look like a pattern, and the mind, seeking an explanation, often locates the pattern in the self rather than in the choices, the circumstances, or the people involved. That is partly because the self is the one constant across all of those experiences, and partly because self-blame offers an illusion of control: if the problem is me, then I can fix it by changing myself. The research on attachment and breakup distress supports this concern. Davis and colleagues found that attachment-related anxiety was associated with greater preoccupation and more extreme distress, and that repeated losses can deepen those patterns if they are not interrupted by new, safer experiences [12]. A person who has been hurt repeatedly may begin to expect hurt, and that expectation can shape how they behave in a new relationship, making them either hypervigilant, constantly scanning for betrayal, or avoidant, keeping a new partner at a distance so that disappointment cannot reach them. Both strategies protect against pain in the short term, and both make trust harder in the long term.
Trust, in this context, is not a single thing. It is at least three things: trust in one's own judgement, trust in a specific partner, and trust in relationships in general. Damage to one does not automatically mean damage to all three, but the three are linked. A person who no longer trusts their own judgement will find it hard to trust a partner's reassurances, because they will wonder whether they are being fooled again. A person who no longer trusts relationships in general will find it hard to invest in a new one, because they will expect it to end badly. Rebuilding trust therefore has to happen in stages, and it often begins not with a new romantic partner, but with smaller, safer forms of trust: trusting a friend with a difficult truth and being met with kindness, trusting oneself to set a boundary and keep it, trusting a therapist to hold a painful story without judgement. Each small experience of trust kept is evidence that trust is still possible, and that evidence, accumulated over time, is what gradually repairs confidence.
It is important to say, clearly, that self-doubt after a bad experience does not mean a person's judgement is broken. It means their judgement was operating with incomplete information, under the influence of hope, desire, and attachment, in a situation where the other person may not have been honest. That is a normal human situation, not a personal defect. The work of recovery is not to become a perfect judge of character, which no one is, but to become a kinder and more accurate judge of oneself: to recognise what one wanted, what one ignored, what one will ask for next time, and to do so without turning a painful lesson into a lifelong verdict.
6. Why Separating Sex from Feeling Is So Hard
Experts also note that separating physical intimacy from emotional attachment is not always easy. While every individual experiences relationships differently, many find that emotional bonds naturally form after becoming physically close. If the relationship ends suddenly or without clear communication, lingering emotional pain may follow.